I wish I could remember the one from my childhood. I wrote it down and put it in my underwear drawer so I wouldn’t lose it when I was about 8… and I lost it.

The spades go…
Eeny meenie popsiceenie
Oh Aw, ugaleeny
Achy, Cachy, Liberache
Say the magic words:
A peach, a plum,
a half a stick of chewing gum,
and if you want the other half,
this is what you say:
(But then I forget!!! I think there’s something about a trash can lid, maybe. Anyone know that version?)